· shop · 17 min read

Sizzle and Sear: 20 Best Broiler Pans for Perfectly Crispy Dishes

Explore the top broiler pans on the market, providing detailed reviews and insights to help you choose the perfect, easy-to-clean option for your next grilled or roasted meal.

Explore the top broiler pans on the market, providing detailed reviews and insights to help you choose the perfect, easy-to-clean option for your next grilled or roasted meal.

If you’re a fan of BBQing or broiling meats, then a broiler pan is a must-have in your kitchen. In this article, we’ve rounded up some of the best broiler pans available on the market, each offering unique features and impressive performance. From durable materials to easy cleaning, we’ve got you covered. So sit back, relax, and get ready to discover the perfect broiler pan for your culinary adventures.

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you

Reviews

Stock Your Home 10-Pack Durable Broiler Pans

Stock Your Home 10-Pack Durable Broiler Pans | Image

Introducing Stock Your Home’s Oven Broiler Pans, a set of 10 disposable aluminum foil sheet pans designed for effortless grilling and cooking. These pans are perfect for roasting meat, fish, and vegetables, with a ribbed bottom surface for a barbecue-like texture. With dimensions of approximately 13.4 inches by 9 inches, they’re a great fit for small grill setups, toaster ovens, and portable cookers alike. When you’re done, simply dispose of them, saving time on clean-up and providing a more eco-friendly option. With a 4.1-star rating and reviews praising their durability and easy clean-up, Stock Your Home’s Oven Broiler Pans make a smart choice for any cook.

Nonstick Broiler Pan for Easy Clean-Up and Healthier Cooking

Nonstick Broiler Pan for Easy Clean-Up and Healthier Cooking | Image

Experience effortless cooking with this Smart Choice Basic Broiler Pan. Its nonstick surface means easy cleanup, while its bottom tray can be used separately for roasting and baking. With improved heat distribution, it works well with almost all ovens, promoting healthier cooking. The durable construction stands up for high-temperature broiling, while its venting slits and serrated design ensure even results. The large capacity allows you to broil family-sized portions effortlessly, and it’s dishwasher safe for added convenience.

Heavy Duty Broiler Pan with Porcelain Grill

Heavy Duty Broiler Pan with Porcelain Grill | Image

Introducing the Range Kleen BP102X 2 Piece Heavy Duty Broiler Pan - a game-changer for your oven. Say goodbye to messy, dirty pans and hello to the stick-free porcelain grill. This 2-piece set measures 16.5 x 13 x 1-3/4 inches and fits perfectly in your oven. Its high heat allows for quick, healthy cooking, while the fat drips away as it collects in the base pan below. A perfect addition to any kitchen for a variety of dishes, including fish, beef, pork, roasts, and veggies.

Replacement GE Broiler Pan and Rack Set

Replacement GE Broiler Pan and Rack Set | Image

Introducing the ultimate replacement for your GE WB48X10056 Broiler Pan and Rack Set, designed to work with a variety of brands. This Premium Broiler Pan and Roasting Rack combo not only fits perfectly, but also enhances your cooking experience. Say goodbye to splatter and smoke, as this set allows air to circulate around your food while draining away juices, ensuring evenly cooked meals every time.

GE Universal Range Broiler Pan: Perfect Oven Solution

GE Universal Range Broiler Pan: Perfect Oven Solution | Image

Pristine and durable, the GE Universal Range Broiler Pan is a versatile and easy-to-clean addition to your oven. Perfect for cooking family-sized portions, its venting slits and serrated design ensure even results. With a heavy-duty porcelain enamel finish, this pan stands up to high temperatures and maintains its gleaming appearance. Dishwasher safe for added convenience, it’s a fantastic accessory for any oven enthusiast.

Premium Broiler Pan for Grilling and Baking in Ranges

Premium Broiler Pan for Grilling and Baking in Ranges | Image

Experience mouth-watering grilled dishes with the Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan. Designed for seamless air fryer oven use, it’s versatile enough for both crispy bacon and delicate grilled vegetables. The bottom pan works wonderfully for baking delicious treats like sheet cakes and casseroles, while the heavy-duty porcelain boasts a stick-free finish for effortless cleaning.

Stainless Steel 246597-1 Broiler Pan with Non-Stick Quality and Large Capacity

Stainless Steel 246597-1 Broiler Pan with Non-Stick Quality and Large Capacity | Image

Experience hassle-free broiling with this sturdy Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan. Its large 12” x 16” size and durable stainless steel construction make it a reliable choice for your kitchen. Designed to withstand high temperatures, this broiler pan is perfect for those who prefer a non-stick surface. Two pieces are included for added flexibility, and the bottom trays can be used separately for roasting or baking. With a 4.6-star rating and glowing reviews, this broiler pan is sure to impress.

Cuisinart Toaster Oven Broiler Pan with Rack - Non-Stick Steel and Durable Design

Cuisinart Toaster Oven Broiler Pan with Rack - Non-Stick Steel and Durable Design | Image

Enjoy hassle-free baking, roasting, and broiling with the Cuisinart ToasterToaster Oven Broiling Pan with Rack! This 8.6-inch-by-11.2-inch pan is the perfect size for your small toastersmall toaster oven, ensuring a snug fit without compromising on performance. Its heavy gauge aluminum construction provides even heating, while the non-stick interior and exterior make cleaning a breeze. The pan is dishwasher safe and comes with a limited lifetime warranty. Simply measure the interior of your toaster oven to ensure compatibility before making your purchase.

Stainless Steel Broiler Pan for High-Temperature Cooking

Stainless Steel Broiler Pan for High-Temperature Cooking | Image

Enhance your broiling experience with Sur La Table’s Stainless Steel Broiler Pan, an essential tool for effortless cooking and easy cleanup. This robust stainless steel pan withstands high temperatures, perfect for those sizzling steaks and scrumptious roasts. The sturdy design allows for seamless dishwasher cleaning, while the bottom trays can be used independently for roasting or baking. A must-have for every home cook seeking a durable and versatile addition to their kitchen arsenal.

Empava Single Wall Oven Compatible Broiler Pan with Built-In Hammock

Empava Single Wall Oven Compatible Broiler Pan with Built-In Hammock | Image

This sleek and versatile oven broiling pan, boasting a durable porcelain finish, seamlessly complements the Empava 24-inch single wall oven. It’s an effortless addition to your kitchen, as it requires no tools for installation and is compatible with the Empava’s strict quality specifications. Ideal for baking enthusiasts, its heavy-duty construction ensures exceptional resistance to corrosion and rust.

GE WB48X10056 Heavy-Duty Broiler Pan

GE WB48X10056 Heavy-Duty Broiler Pan | Image

This versatile George Foreman broiler pan, with a rating of 4.7 out of 5, enables you to effortlessly cook your favorite meats and veggies, in record time, with even results. Designed for high-temperature broiling, the robust pan features venting slits and a serrated surface, ensuring perfectly even cooking. Suitable for large family gatherings, the generous capacity accommodates portion-sized servings, while its dishwasher-safe design saves you time on cleanup. Give your culinary skills a boost and serve up mouth-watering dishes with this popular and highly-rated broiler pan.

Durable Whirlpool Broiler Pan Replacement

Durable Whirlpool Broiler Pan Replacement | Image

Upgrade your Whirlpool stove with this high-quality Broiler Pan from Kitchen Basics 101. Perfectly fitting most brands like GE and Whirlpool, this porcelain-finished pan is both durable and dishwasher safe. Dimensions of 16.5” by 12.5” allow for ample space for your food, and its American-made construction ensures long-lasting performance.

Certified Appliance Heavy Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan & Grill Set

Certified Appliance Heavy Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan & Grill Set | Image

Experience the versatility of the Heavy-Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grill Set, perfect for replacing damaged or soiled broiler pans and ideal for both indoor and outdoor use. Its 16.75-inch length and 13-inch width ensure ample space for the perfect grill, while the porcelain finish guarantees easy, quick cleanup. Users appreciate its robust build and durability, with the non-stick coating making cleaning a breeze. From meatloaf to outdoor grilling, this versatile set delivers top-notch results every time.

Whirlpool Genuine Broiler Pan for Efficient Cooking

Whirlpool Genuine Broiler Pan for Efficient Cooking | Image

The Genuine Whirlpool Broiler Pan, available in a sleek black finish, is the perfect addition to your oven, providing a durable and efficient cooking surface. This porcelain broiler pan not only enhances the flavor of your dishes, but also ensures effortless cleanup by allowing juices to flow off food into the conveniently placed porcelain pan below. With its streamlined design and versatile usage, this broiler pan is sure to become a staple in your kitchen, making mealtime a breeze.

Sturdy Broiler Pan for Easy Oven Cooking

Sturdy Broiler Pan for Easy Oven Cooking | Image

Satisfy all your food prep, cooking, and serving needs with the compact Wilton Broiler Grid & Pan, Small. Experience hassle-free cleaning thanks to its non-stick coating, and enjoy even heat distribution throughout due to its heavy-gauge steel construction. This pan is a perfect fit for small ovens and toaster ovens, making it a versatile addition to your kitchen.

Classic Porcelain-Enameled Steel Broiler Pan with Chrome Grill

Classic Porcelain-Enameled Steel Broiler Pan with Chrome Grill | Image

Introducing the Range Kleen Porcelain Broiler Pan, a timeless addition to any kitchen. This classic broiler pan features a top grill combined with a base that can be used separately as a baking dish. Perfect for grilling your favorite foods, from meat and seafood to fresh veggies, this heavy-duty, porcelain-enameled steel pan ensures easy cleaning and lasting durability. Its sleek design allows for easy draining of fats and oils during broiling, while its extra-deep base can be used on its own for baking. Safe to use up to 1025 degrees F, this broiler pan is a thoughtful and functional replacement for original pans in older ovens or a versatile addition to any modern oven. Made in the USA with exact original range manufacturer specifications, this is a must-have for any home cook.

Classic Broiler Pan for Healthy Cooking

Classic Broiler Pan for Healthy Cooking | Image

Savor the taste of perfectly seared meals with the Nordic Ware Naturals Classic Broiler Pan, carefully crafted to enhance your culinary journey. Made from durable materials that can withstand high temperatures, this versatile essential is perfect for broiling your favorite meats and vegetables. The ribbed broiling rack elevates your food, ensuring even cooking and prevention of sticking, resulting in a crispy exterior and a juicy interior. Whether you’re preparing a quick weeknight meal or a special occasion dinner, this classic broiler pan is the perfect addition to your kitchen.

Premium Heavy-Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan & Grill Set

Premium Heavy-Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan & Grill Set | Image

Experience the convenience of the Heavy-Duty Porcelain Broiler Pan & Grill Set, an essential addition to any kitchen or outdoor grill. This top-quality product is specifically designed to replace worn-out or factory-missing broiler pans, making it perfect for broiling, grilling, and baking with ease. With its heavy-duty construction, it ensures durability and reliability, while its PFOA-PTFE-free coating guarantees a safe and healthy cooking experience. The perfect size for small families, this sturdy and well-made broiler pan can be easily cleaned and fits seamlessly into various cooking spaces, providing a stress-free and enjoyable cooking experience every time.

Wilton Broiler Pan with Non-Stick Surface for Oven - Large Capacity

Wilton Broiler Pan with Non-Stick Surface for Oven - Large Capacity | Image

Experience hassle-free cooking with the Wilton Broiler Pan. Its heavy-gauge steel and non-stick metal provide even heat distribution and quick clean-up, making it a delight to use. The pan’s dimensions are conveniently embossed on the handle for easy handling, and its reinforced coating ensures a durable, long-lasting surface. Whether you’re grilling food indoors or outdoors, this broiler pan is the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal.

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black

Whirlpool Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid, Black | Image

The Whirlpool Broiler Pan & Grid is a convenient addition to your cooking arsenal. Designed with a grid structure that helps minimize splatter and smoke, this pan effectively drains away liquid content, making it perfect for grilling, broiling, and roasting. Featuring a porcelain coating that ensures easy cleaning and a dishwasher-safe grid plate, this pan is both easy to maintain and versatile in its use. With a sturdy build and a black finish that adds a touch of class to your kitchen, the Whirlpool Broiler Pan & Grid is a must-have for any avid cook.

Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to preparing delicious and juicy chicken dishes, a broiler pan can make all the difference. This essential kitchen tool helps in evenly cooking chicken while keeping it tender and flavorful. However, with the wide variety of options available in the market, choosing the right broiler pan can be a daunting task. To help you make an informed decision, we have compiled a comprehensive buyer’s guide to guide you through the process.

Material

The material of a broiler pan plays a significant role in its durability, ease of use, and cleaning. Some of the most common materials used for broiler pans include aluminum, stainless steel, and cast iron. Aluminum pans are lightweight and inexpensive, making them a popular choice. Stainless steel pans offer excellent heat distribution and are known for their longevity. Cast iron pans provide even heat distribution and retain heat well, ensuring perfectly cooked chicken every time.

Broiler-Pan-2

Size

Another important factor to consider when purchasing a broiler pan is its size. A larger pan can accommodate more chicken, which might be helpful if you frequently entertain or prepare meals for a larger family. However, a smaller pan might be more suitable for single or small households. Consider your requirements and the size of your oven when making a decision on the right size of broiler pan for you.

Rib Racks

Many broiler pans come with built-in rib racks, which help in holding the chicken upright and allowing for better airflow. This design not only helps in even cooking but also adds a layer of flavor as the chicken drippings circulate throughout the pan. If you frequently prepare chicken with ribs, consider investing in a broiler pan that comes with rib racks.

Broiler-Pan-3

Cleaning and Maintenance

Easy cleaning and maintenance are crucial factors when choosing a broiler pan. Opt for materials that are non-stick or easy to clean. Additionally, look for pans with removable handles and racks, which makes cleaning more accessible. Regular maintenance, such as seasoning cast iron pans and avoiding abrasive cleaners, can help prolong the life of your broiler pan.

FAQ

Broiler-Pan-4

What is a broiler pan and how is it different from a regular roasting pan?

A broiler pan is a pan specifically designed for broiling, which means cooking close to a heating element, such as an oven’s broiler. This pan is typically smaller than a regular roasting pan, and it has slats or holes on its bottom to allow heat to circulate underneath the food. The difference between a broiler pan and a regular roasting pan lies in their size, slatted bottom, and design, which enables better airflow and heat circulation during the cooking process.

Regular roasting pans, on the other hand, are larger and do not have slats on the bottom. These pans are ideal for slow-roasting and baking, as the food is placed directly on the pan surface. Roasting pans may or may not have a rack to elevate the food for even cooking, depending on the model. Both types of pans are available in various materials like aluminum or stainless steel.

What are the benefits of using a broiler pan?

There are several benefits to using a broiler pan, such as faster cooking time and even heat distribution. The slats or holes on the bottom of a broiler pan allow for better airflow and heat circulation under the food, accelerating the cooking process. This slatted bottom also prevents sticking, making clean-up easier and reducing the need for additional cooking spray or oil. Additionally, broiler pans allow for the creation of crispy, flavorful skin on meats, as the heat surrounds the food from all sides.

Another advantage of using a broiler pan is that it requires less preheating time compared to a roasting pan, which can be time-consuming. This is especially useful when preparing quick meals or when hosting a large gathering and having multiple dishes to cook at once. Furthermore, broiler pans are smaller than roasting pans, making them a space-saving option for smaller kitchens.

Broiler-Pan-5

Can I place a broiler pan on the stovetop?

Yes, you can use a broiler pan as a stovetop pan. Many broiler pans are designed to be compatible with stovetops and can withstand direct heat. However, it is always recommended to check the user manual or the product specifications to verify if your broiler pan is suitable for stovetop use. Using a broiler pan on the stovetop can help you save time by cooking and broiling food simultaneously, as well as allow you to brown and sear food easily.

It is essential to note that not all broiler pans can be used on the stovetop due to potential damage from direct heat. Therefore, it is crucial to consult the manufacturer’s guidelines and ensure that your broiler pan is compatible with stovetop use before proceeding. Always use caution and follow the recommended cooking methods to ensure safe and effective use of your broiler pan.

What materials are broiler pans typically made of?

Broiler pans are usually made of lightweight and durable materials such as aluminum or stainless steel. Aluminum is a popular choice for broiler pans because it is lightweight, affordable, and very conductive, which ensures even heating and faster cooking. However, aluminum is prone to discoloration and corrosion if not properly maintained.

Stainless steel, on the other hand, offers excellent durability and resistance to corrosion, making it a more popular choice for high-end and commercial-grade broiler pans. Stainless steel broiler pans tend to be more expensive but offer long-lasting performance without the need for frequent replacement. Many stainless steel models also feature non-stick coatings to make clean-up even easier.

Broiler-Pan-6

Are broiler pans dishwasher safe?

Yes, most broiler pans are dishwasher safe, which makes cleaning up after cooking easier and more convenient. However, it is essential to check the user manual or the product’s specifications to ensure that your broiler pan is dishwasher safe. Some broiler pans may have non-stick coatings or be made of materials that require hand washing to maintain their durability and performance.

When cleaning a dishwasher-safe broiler pan, it’s recommended to place it on the top rack to avoid potential damage from the high heat generated during the washing cycle. Additionally, it’s a good idea to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines on proper cleaning methods, such as using a gentle detergent and avoiding abrasive materials or steel wool.

How do I prevent food from sticking to the broiler pan?

To prevent sticking of food to the broiler pan, it’s crucial to properly prepare and season the pan before cooking. You can do this by coating the pan with a thin layer of cooking spray, oil, or butter. This will help create a non-stick surface and make cleanup easier after cooking. Additionally, using a silicone baking mat or parchment paper liner on the bottom of the pan can further reduce the risk of sticking and make cleanup even more straightforward.

Another tip is to avoid overcrowding the pan when cooking. Overcrowded food can easily stick together, making cleanup more challenging. Instead, cook food in a single layer, with a little space between each item to allow for even heat distribution and easier clean-up. Lastly, remember to wash and dry the broiler pan thoroughly before using it again, as any residue or moisture can contribute to sticking.

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you

    Share:
    Back to Blog